Sunday, 11 December 2011

Good Fences Make Good Neighbours?


Perhaps the irony of Robert Frost's poem was lost on the current and previous US administration. The over-securitization of the Canadian-American border, complete with customs "pre-clearance", snarling line-ups at border crossings and the wasting of billions of dollars on the deployment of sophisticated surveillance technologies, is hurting Canadian-American relations. I was moved by this story, because I grew up on both sides of the border, come from a mixed family, and cross between the two countries on a regular basis. The sheer ignorance of most Americans concerning the important relationship with Canada is staggering. Canada is the United States' largest trade partner, for imports and exports.

What's more troubling is something we cannot break down into percentages and fact sheets. The over-securitization of the Canadian-American frontier is harming cross-border relationships at the most elemental level. Old friends cannot pop over for tea. American border guards, trained on the Mexican border and attuned to different realities, spit out orders at little old ladies in noisy, poorly constructed bus depots on the Québec border. When I land in Canada, coming from anywhere in the world, I always breathe a sigh of relief. I seldom feel at ease crossing into the United States. I see a country gripped by hysteria losing its direction.

What's worse, all of these systems will not stop an attacker who is comfortable giving his life to complete his act. No one in the world can prevent such insane violence, but through the imposition of this state of security, we have to live with such tension everyday.

I hope one day these foolish little fences will come down. If the EU can do it, surely we North Americans can as well.

No comments:

Post a Comment